The MFT did not catch a break with the court assigned to its lawsuit against the Missouri State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors and Catholic Fraternal Life. The hearing scheduled for September 28th was continued for another four weeks, and in the meantime, the parties continue to file evidentiary discovery requests. The Association’s
Master Trusts
The Missouri Funeral Trust and its Catch-22
A status hearing is scheduled for September 28th in the lawsuit filed by the Missouri Funeral Trust against the State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors and Catholic Fraternal Life. The lawsuit is now 4 months removed from the request for a temporary restraining order that, among other relief sought, would stay the financial…
The MFT Lawsuit Claims: The Client List
The lawsuit brought by the Missouri Funeral Trust against the Missouri State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors and CFL Pre-Need includes a number of unique and dubious claims. For example, the lawsuit defines CFL Pre-Need, an insurance company, as a competitor but not funeral home clients that are licensed as a preneed seller. The…
Trust Shortages: Sponsorship Fees
It was been almost 7 years since we posted the piece titled “Trade Association Membership: weighing the costs vs. the benefits”. Towards the end of that article, we discuss how the master trust sponsor fee provides a crucial source of revenue to state associations. That post was written subsequent to the dissolution of…
Preneed Trust Shortages: Investment Management Fees
One strength of the state association master trust is that it can provide the ‘critical mass’ required for economies of scale to reduce trust management costs. As the state master trust grows in size, the association can better negotiate asset management arrangements. However, the reality has been very different for these programs. The reorganization of…
Missouri Funeral Trust: Seeking a Gag Order
On July 27th, a Missouri court will consider a motion filed by the Missouri State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors to be dismissed from the lawsuit filed by the Missouri Funeral Trust. One of the allegations made by the Missouri Funeral Trust was that confidential information obtained by a state auditor regarding the program’s…
Preneed Trust Shortages: Missouri’s Income Withdrawals
Prior to Missouri re-writing its preneed law in 2009, preneed sellers could draw off realized income so long as the withdrawal did not reduce the trust’s fair market value below trust deposits. Seeking income, many Missouri sellers directed their trustees to invest in bonds. As interest rates declined during the early part of the prior…
Missouri and Preneed Deficiencies: What is a shortage?
At its June meeting, the Missouri State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors gave instructions to their staff to draft legislation that would provide the Board powers to force preneed sellers to contribute funds to their trusts to cover ‘shortages’. The instruction was not without some controversy as one Board member questioned why he was…
Association Master Trusts: De Facto Trustees
According to court filings, the reorganization plans for the Wisconsin Master Trust and California Master Trust each seek to eliminate ‘de facto trustee’ relationships that allowed the respective associations’ executives to ‘misuse, misspend, and mismanage millions of dollars’ of trust funds, and to direct funds towards inappropriate and unsuitable investments that served the association’s, rather…
Transparency:The Curious Case of the Missouri Funeral Trust
In his final report to the court, the Wisconsin Master Trust receiver proposed a new trust agreement that is intended to provide “transparency, accountability, oversight and prudence”. Similarly, the California Attorney General seeks to provide transparency through express reporting requirements included in the trust agreement proposed to the court presiding over the California Master…