On August 30, 2021, the legal saga of National Prearranged Services came to a rather anticlimactic conclusion. In a relatively short decision, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed Judge Richard Webber’s July 2019 judgment that awarded $102,135,393.07 damages against PNC Bank, a successor to the NPS preneed trusts. The final damages award is a
Fiduciary
NPS’ Trial Court: Trustees and Individual Deposit Records
“Allegiant [Bank] violated the industry standard of care by not maintaining consumer-level deposit records, because, as here, where there are multiple beneficiaries of a trust, the trustee must keep records of the individual deposits made for each consumer.”
This finding by the trial court in the NPS civil trial had to come as a shock…
National Prearranged Services: A Serious Lack of Fiduciary Oversight
National Prearranged Services is back in the news after a trial court issued a new $102 million judgment against PNC Bank (the corporate successor of Allegiant Bank). Allegiant Bank served as NPS’ Missouri preneed trustee for six years beginning in 1998. When PNC Bank agreed to purchase Allegiant in 2004, PNC performed due diligence that…
The 1041QFT: Twenty Years and Still a Puzzle to Some
Tax Code Section 685 has now been law for 21 years, and this marks our 20th year of preparing the Qualified Funeral Trust return. (And more specifically, the composite QFT return) The QFT return was meant to simplify income reporting for a trust that has hundreds, or even thousands, of contract beneficiaries. Yet, we…
Preneed Trust Shortages: Investment Management Fees
One strength of the state association master trust is that it can provide the ‘critical mass’ required for economies of scale to reduce trust management costs. As the state master trust grows in size, the association can better negotiate asset management arrangements. However, the reality has been very different for these programs. The reorganization of…
The NPS Civil Trial: our first glimpse of the legal arguments
In anticipation of a February trial date, a group from the fiduciary bank defendants has filed a motion for summary judgment in the Federal court that will try the NPS civil lawsuit. The intent of the summary judgment request is to narrow the scope of claims made by the Special Deputy Receiver. The pleadings filed…
The Fed’s Tapering Plan: A Bumpy Road for Death Care Trusts?
It has been almost ten years since the return on Government bonds fell below 5%. But bond returns did not hit bottom until four years later when the sub-prime mortgage market collapsed. Those conditions threatened the nation’s credit markets, and so, in 2008, the Federal Reserve Board initiated a stimulus program involving the purchase of…
Missouri and the Investment Advisor: A Chinese Wall
Among the rule proposals suggested by the Division of Professional Registration to the State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors was the following definition of “External Investment Advisor”:
any licensed, qualified investment advisor approved and authorized by the trustee of the preneed trust and who holds no personal interest in any assets of the preneed …
The NPS Criminal Trial: Vicarious Liability?
David Wulf may stand alone in the crosshairs of the criminal prosecutors, but his fate will impact the NPS preneed trustees (and possibly other registered investment advisors who manage death care funds).
Mr. Wulf had a situation that is unique from what existed in Illinois, Wisconsin, and Tennessee, but is familiar to other death care…
Michigan’s Plan: Target Date Investment Strategy
I stand corrected.
A representative of the Michigan Funeral Directors Association advises that their request for proposal for a new investment advisor for the master trust has resulted in the selection of a firm that will not only assume a true fiduciary relationship to funeral directors and consumers, but that will also guide the Association…